How The Mai Tai Was Invented

A glass filled with a drink next to sliced fruit and flowers

Most people picture the same thing when they hear Mai Tai: something orange, sweet and full of pineapple juice, usually with an umbrella in it. The original contained no pineapple at all.

The drink it actually was tells you a great deal about mid century American bar culture, and about how quickly a recipe can be mangled.

Oakland, 1944

The accepted story credits Victor Bergeron, better known as Trader Vic, at his restaurant in Oakland, California. He was serving friends visiting from Tahiti, Ham and Carrie Guild, and built them something around a bottle of 17 year old J. Wray & Nephew Jamaican rum he’d been saving.

Carrie tasted it and said “Maita’i roa ae”, which translates loosely as out of this world. The name stuck. Bergeron’s own account, published decades later, is charming and possibly tidied up in the retelling, though the rum itself is well documented.

The Actual Recipe

The 1944 build’s simple by tiki standards. Two ounces of aged Jamaican rum, half an ounce of orange curaçao, a quarter ounce of rock candy syrup, half an ounce of orgeat, and the juice of one lime with the spent shell dropped into the glass. Shaken with crushed ice, poured unstrained, garnished with mint.

Notice what’s absent. No pineapple, no orange juice, no grenadine, no dark float, no umbrella. The flavour comes from the rum and the orgeat, which is an almond syrup with a slight bitterness that most modern versions replace with something sweeter.

The Dispute With Donn Beach

Donn Beach, founder of Don the Beachcomber and the man who essentially invented tiki, claimed he’d made the drink first in 1933. His version, a Q.B. Cooler, contained honey, ginger, falernum, soda and several rums, and it doesn’t resemble Bergeron’s build very closely.

The claim’s never been settled and probably can’t be. The two men were competitors who borrowed liberally from each other, and neither kept the sort of records that would resolve it. Most drinks historians favour Bergeron on the strength of the recipe similarity, while acknowledging that Donn Beach created the world in which the Mai Tai made sense.

How It Went Wrong

Tropical Trio. A Still Life of Refreshments on a Rustic Wooden Tray, A Warm Light

The drink travelled to Hawaii in the 1950s, where the Matson Line hotels put it on their menus and started adding pineapple and orange juice. Volume was the reason. Fruit juice is cheap, it stretches the expensive rum, and holidaymakers liked it sweet.

By the 1970s the Mai Tai on most menus was a premix pour with a paper parasol. The original spec survived mainly in Trader Vic’s own restaurants, and the modern revival owes a lot to Jeff “Beachbum” Berry, who spent years tracking down lost tiki recipes and publishing them. If you enjoy this sort of argument, the history of the Zombie cocktail involves the same two figures and an even messier trail of evidence.

Making A Proper One

Use an aged Jamaican rum with real pot still character, since the 17 year old Wray & Nephew original is long gone and blending’s now standard. Many bars split the base between a Jamaican rum and an aged Martinique agricole, which gets closer to the depth of the original bottle.

Buy decent orgeat or make it, because the supermarket versions taste like marzipan and will flatten the drink. Squeeze the lime fresh, don’t skip dropping the shell in, and serve it over crushed ice with a generous mint sprig positioned so you smell it as you drink.

Where To Drink One

Ours is built to the 1944 spec, using rums drawn from a collection of more than 400 bottles and served in handmade glassware. At Rhum Tavern, we’re a stylish drinks spot near Oxford Circus, two minutes from the station at 48 Margaret Street, with a full cocktail list, litre beers and a flame grilled food menu.

Book a table and order one. It’s an odd home for a Californian cocktail invented in Oakland, and it works anyway.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does A Mai Tai Contain Pineapple Juice?

The original 1944 recipe doesn’t. Pineapple and orange juice were added by Hawaiian hotel bars in the 1950s to make the drink cheaper and sweeter, and that version became the one most people know.

What Rum Should I Use In A Mai Tai?

An aged Jamaican rum with pot still character comes closest to the original. Many bartenders blend it with an aged agricole from Martinique to add complexity, since the specific rum Trader Vic used hasn’t been available for decades.

What Is Orgeat?

An almond syrup, traditionally made with orange flower water and sometimes a little rose water. It gives the Mai Tai its nutty backbone, and the quality of the orgeat makes more difference to the finished drink than almost anything besides the rum.

Who Invented The Mai Tai?

Victor Bergeron, known as Trader Vic, is generally credited with creating it in Oakland in 1944. Donn Beach of Don the Beachcomber claimed an earlier version from 1933, and the dispute has never been formally settled.

Is A Mai Tai A Strong Cocktail?

Yes, reasonably. A properly made one contains around 60ml of rum plus curaçao, with only lime and orgeat to soften it. The fruit juice versions are weaker by volume, which is part of why they became popular.

Related Posts